Town planner to appeal 'sinful' character home plan

The Burns St home.
The Burns St home. Contributed

A TOWN planner will appeal a unanimous Toowoomba Regional Council decision to refuse an application cutting a heritage-listed block in half, despite meeting all requirements for approval.

East Toowoomba resident Carolen Collins wanted to subdivide her Burns St block into two, effectively cutting it in half with plans to build another home on the Bruce St frontage at the rear.

The street is in the Neighbourhood Character Overlay area, and records show the existing house was built in 1910.

The application included the plan to demolish a garage at the rear of the Burns St block.

As a code assessable application, the public was not allowed to make submissions on the plan, but Cr Chris Tait, as chair of the special meeting at city hall, opened the floor to concerned neighbours.

Burns St resident Eleanor Cullen took the floor with concerns regarding parking and the aesthetic impact on the streetscape.

Of particular issue was where the likely increased number of cars would park, she said.

"Cars were not thought of, especially for these houses which were worker cottages," Mrs Cullen said.

"The only type of vehicle, type of transport, was a bike and even when they first went there, they used to wait for the siren at the foundry and go off to work.

"It was never designed for the use of cars."

Several councillors aired their concerns including Cr Joe Ramia who labelled any change to the front of the house to make way for a carpark would be sinful.

"It would be an absolute sin to butcher the front of that house," he said.

Cr Carol Taylor's motion that the application be rejected was unanimously supported.

Mrs Collins and town planner Andrew Hill said they would appeal.

"The Planning Act 2016 clearly states that where the development complies with acceptable assessment benchmarks it must be approved. Not should, not may - must," he said.

"This means my client will have to cover additional expense to take this to the Planning and Environment Court where it will be immediately overturned because it should not have been refused."

Mrs Collins said she had wanted to divide the block to put it to use.

"I want to build a small place down the back and someone else can take it over," she said.

Topics:  appeal court east toowoomba heritage history planning and environment court toowoomba regional council town planning

Stay Connected

Update your news preferences and get the latest news delivered to your inbox.

Neglected cemetery leaves residents fuming

North Burnett cemetery's are being neglected and residents are not happy.

THE North Burnett Regional Council has apologised to the Eidsvold.

Artist paints a picture of community spirit at St Joseph's

MURAL UNVEILED: Susie Capewell delivered her artist statement to St Joseph's Primary School on Monday, March 19.

Time, talent and treasure was the recipe for a local mural.

Hornets buzz as Mustangs left ragged

A Mustangs player makes it to the try lines against the Hornets.

It was the clash of the century with Cherbourg Hornets.

Local Partners